Connie Rector was the son of Lee Rector and Catherine Trigg.3 He grew up near Arkadelphia, AR, mostly without the presence of his father, who died when he was young.4 When he was 20, he married Gertrude McCloud5 and together, the couple had one son, Tom. The family, however, appears to have eventually been broken up.6 Rector remained in the Arkadelphia area until at least the latter 1910s, working as plumber.7
As the 1920 season went on, Rector left the Texas Colored League and joined the Hilldale Club of Darby, PA. Rector may have earned the job through his connection with Louis Santop, a veteran Negro baseball catcher with whom Rector had been a teammate in Fort Worth earlier in the season.12 With Hilldale, an independent club, Rector pitched against various teams, including Babe Ruth and his barnstorming All-star team.13 Rector finished the 1920 season with Hilldale and returned to play with the team in 1921 and 1922, during which the club operated in association with the Negro National League. Rector's playing time was split between pitching and outfielding, and in both cases, he was generally productive, but was often reserved for relief roles.
Midway through the 1922 season, Rector shifted to the Brooklyn Royal Giants of the Eastern Colored League. In doing so, he rejoined his former teammate Charles Spearman for several seasons. Over time, Rector proved himself to be an effective starter of some notoriety for Brooklyn,14 but was often delegated to the outfield amid a crowded pitching staff that included Brooklyn regulars Dick Redding, Bill Holland, and Willis Flourney.
As Rector progressed into his forties, he continued to appear for the Black Yankees as a regular starter and reliever through 1935. However, as he began to decline with age, he began to bounce around with various New York teams. Early in the 1936 season, Rector briefly became manager of a local upstart team known as the New York Black Crusaders,23 but returned by mid season to the Black Yankees, which had entered the revived Negro National League.24 The following year, Rector joined the lesser independent Brooklyn Royal Giants, but again returned to the Black Yankees at the start of 1938. Midway through the season, he shifted to the New York Cubans and remained with the team through 1939.25 From there, he pitched for the Royal Giants26 and Norwalk Crusaders in 1940,27 the Black Yankees in 1941, the Pennsylvania Red Caps28 and Royal Giants in 1942,29 and the Black Yankees and Royal Giants in 1943.30 Rector's farewell season in Negro baseball finally came in 1944 at age 52 when he appeared as a regular reliever and starter with the Black Yankees. Despite his age, he occasionally turned in effective outings, including a complete game against the Baltimore Elite Giants in July.31 Rector subsequently retired from baseball, having played twenty-six professional seasons.
Rector died in May, 1963, in New York.32
"Manager R. Lee Jones of the Dallas Giants stated that he has signed . . . an in fielder, Cornelius Rector"33
"Rector [t]he Arkadelphian went the whole rout for the locals [Dallas Black Giants] . . . "34
"Chaney White and Willis Rector will cavort in the pastures of the Philadelphia Hilldales the coming season. White and Rector are also former Giants and Panthers."36
"Rector is pitcher of parts and a better-than-ordinary outfielder."37
" . . . Connie Rector, recently acquired right-hand pitcher from the Bronx Giants [by the New York Lincoln Giants] in exchange for "Highpockets" Hudspeth. . . . Rector is a chunky fellow from Arkansas . . . "38
"Experience, ability and physical stamina are all embodied in the chunky right-hander [Rector] from Arkadelphia, Ark."39
" . . . Connie Rector, star right-hander of the Lincoln Giants. Rector has by far the best record for the year with a total of 20 games won against 3 lost."40
"We were awfully sorry that we had to miss both the wedding ceremony and the reception of Leona White, one of Philadelphia's most popular and efficient young women who was married to the equally popular ball player, Cornelius Rector, of New York City, on Saturday afternoon, at 3:30. Rev. William A. Harrod, of Cherry Memorial, joined the couple in matrimony. . . . The bride . . . entered the parlor of her attractively decorated home, 2040 Master Street on the arm of her father, Mr. Matthew C. White. . . . The best man was Leland Carter. . . . And so --the band new Mr. and Mrs. Cornelius Rector are now honeymooning in Atlantic City, following a strenuous round of pre-nuptial fetes, which must needs have betokened-- most eloquently-- the admiration of a host of friends!"41
"Connie Rector probably has been in the game longer than any other individual now playing . . . And Connie came up with a terrific hurling feat recently over in Yankees Stadium."42
"His able opponent in the duel was loquacious Connie Rector, Royal Giant veteran who talked while pitching to anyone who would carry on a conversation. Rector was much more generous with his speech than with fat pitches, however."43
"In the nightcap, the [Baltimore Elite]Giants were forced to come from behind to defeat veteran Connie Rector, who went into the seventh and final frame leading 2-1, with Jonas Gaines on the mound."44
Statistics at Baseball-Reference.com.
Statistics at Seamheads.com.
2 Rector's mother, Catherine (nee Trigg) Rector, was the sister of Luther and Toussaint Atkinson's mother Isabel (nee Trigg) Atkinson.
3 The 1900 U.S. Census shows Cornelius Rector living with Catherine Rector and two brothers near Arkadelphia. Catherine is listed as the daughter of Anderson and Mandy Trigg and having three living children. The Arkansas County Marriages index shows that Catherine Trigg married Lee Rector in Clark County, AR, on December 14th, 1890.
4 The 1900 U.S. Census lists Catherine Rector as a widow. Her youngest son, Oscar Rector, was born about 1895. Hence, Lee Rector died between 1895-1900 when Rector would have been 3-8.
6 The 1920 U.S. Census, shows Gertrude with Tom living with her parents, Tom and Clarissa McCloud. The 1930 U.S. Census shows Tom still living his grandmother in Collin County, TX. In 1930, Connie Rector remarried.
8 "Sixteen Innings Required", Freeman (Indianapolis), 6/26/1910. A player named "Rector" is mentioned in the game recap. Also mentioned is a "Spearman," which is presumably Charles Spearman.
9 "Hot Springs Reds Win at Malvern, Ark.", Freeman (Indianapolis), 8/19/1911. A player named "Restor" is mentioned in the game recap. Also mentioned is a "Spearman," which is presumably Charles Spearman.
12 According to the Dallas Express, Santop spent the spring of 1920 in Fort Worth, playing for the local Black Panthers. It seems plausible that he, having caught for Rector earlier in the season (Dallas Express, 4/24/1920), could have assisted in earning Rector a job with Hilldale.
19 Pittsburgh Courier, 11/7/1925, p.13 New York Passenger Records show that Rector sailed from San Juan in December, 1925.
22 New York Age, 2/11/1933, p.6; Black Baseball Out of Season: Pay for Play Outside of the Negro Leagues, By William F. McNeil, p.114